The PLoS blog "Take as Directed" has started an interesting discussion based on science journalism and fact checking that was generated by the popular science podcast This Week in Virology that was streamed live at ASM's International Conference on Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy (ICAAC) in Chicago.
During the podcast, Trine Tsouderos, Science/Medical journalist for the Chicago Tribune, acknowledged "her practice of sometimes running quotes, paragraphs, and even full articles past scientists she’s interviewed for fact-checking purposes" which is often perceived as bad form in journalism circles.
Based on this revelation the blog's author David Kroll asks the question, "how do you negotiate this slope of prospectively sharing article content with scientist sources?"
The result is a cascade of comments about the practice.
Also, of interest is Trine Tsouderos' take on comments and why she is against having a comment section for her articles. She feels they don't really ad to her articles one way or another.
Click source to read the blog post and the 86 and counting comments.
Here's the video: