Dutch researchers did *not* create 'an even more deadly strain of the virus in a laboratory'. They produced a strain of the H5N1 virus that transmits in the air among ferrets. This virus is much *less* deadly than the parental virus.
Furthermore, Lipsitch is completely wrong in stating that 'If you make a strain that’s highly transmissible between humans, as the Dutch team did....." The Dutch team did *not* make a strain that can be transmitted among humans.
Why is the H5N1 story filled with incorrect statements and wrong assumptions? It is our job as microbiologists to inform the public of what actually happened, and articles such as this one do a distinct disservice.
I can't believe anyone would rate this performance other than 5 stars. Whether or not you like the music, you have to give 8 scientists a lot of credit for getting up in front of a crowd and performing - not giving a talk but playing music.
Garth, the H5N1 fatality rate is *not* 60% as you cite above. There is serological evidence that many individuals are infected with mild or no symptoms, which would bring the fatality rate below 1%. Please see http://www.virology.ws/2012/01/25/h5n1-facts-not-fear/ for more information on this. We need to stop citing this incorrect rate as it is driving the controversy over publication of H5N1 results.
I think it's a great idea to check facts in science-related stories; I cannot understand why the writers are so opposed to this practice. I checked Rebecca Skloot's 'Immortal Life' in this way and I am sure she is grateful. I've also done it for Trine, as we reveal in TWiV 149.
They did not find Hendra virus in the dog - they find antibodies that react with the virus. This may indicate previous infection with Hendra virus or a related virus.
Indeed, the empowerment of the internet for scientists is quite well known - it allows us to reach many more people than we ever have in our careers. Many scientists are blogging and podcasting and reaching new audiences, which appreciate the direct contact. This is why we just passed one million downloads on TWiV. It would be useful to emphasize such success stories as examples of what scientists can be doing.
I am always curious about why someone would vote a TWiV episode only one star. If you have a specific problem with the episode, please leave a comment so that we can improve it in future episodes.
Miso, thanks for your comments. Glad you liked this slightly different episode. We'll aim to do the same with TWiV. As for TWiB - stay tuned; it's in the planning stages.
This is a colossal waste of money, given that there are many free tools available on the web that enable social interaction among scientists. The funds would have been far better spent supporting the research of new scientists.
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on Clathrin coated vesiclesSat May 18 12:15:32 2013
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on The Deadliest VirusSun Feb 17 14:49:51 2013
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on Event - Synthetic Biology: Life both as you know it ... and as you don’t -Tues. Oct. 23 @busboysandpoets DCMon Oct 22 15:49:26 2012
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on TWiP 42: The tick keeps on tickingThu Aug 16 02:04:37 2012
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on Scientists Discover New Type of Virus Responsible for a Devastating Disease in SnakesWed Aug 15 14:01:27 2012
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on TWiP 41: Flying and crawling beastsTue Aug 7 21:38:07 2012
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on Herpetic Legion - ReactivationSun Jul 29 14:22:08 2012
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on Petri dish artFri Feb 17 12:32:31 2012
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on H5N1 Virus Targets Pulmonary Endothelial CellsSun Jan 29 23:20:25 2012
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on TWiP 33: Hide and seekWed Nov 30 22:27:28 2011
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on Trine Tsouderos on This Week in Virology: When do you fact-check article content with sources?Thu Sep 22 15:40:50 2011
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on Hendra virus found in a dogWed Jul 27 12:09:11 2011
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on 500 Million-Year-Old SymbiosisTue Jul 5 20:58:27 2011
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on 500 Million-Year-Old SymbiosisTue Jul 5 20:57:20 2011
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on Epidemiology and social media: conference failSun Jun 26 18:27:22 2011
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on TWiM #8: Live in NOLAFri Jun 3 21:31:16 2011
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on TWiV 135: Live in the Big EasyWed Jun 1 13:57:25 2011
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on TWiV 126: Wart's up, doc?Fri Apr 1 16:14:32 2011
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on Interview with Tom Shenk about mBio, ASM's new open access journalMon May 17 14:06:48 2010
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on TWiP 9: Mala ariaMon May 10 16:11:36 2010
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on TWiP 8: Frog legs and parasite talesSat Apr 24 11:51:58 2010
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on Facebook for ScientistsWed Apr 14 18:37:58 2010
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on Bacteria May Cause H1N1 Death Rate IncreaseTue Jan 5 17:23:19 2010
Vincent Racaniello
makes this comment
on Swine flu mutation fears may be prematureWed Nov 25 16:18:27 2009